Defending clients in organized crime cases has long been considered one of the most challenging aspects of criminal defense. The points of contention often span both procedural and substantive issues, involving a vast amount of evidence and complex factual determinations. Recently, in an organized crime case handled by attorneys Zhang Qiming and Xu Ming, their arduous efforts during the review and prosecution phase finally succeeded in having the charge of “organized crime” dropped against their client, marking a crucial milestone in the case.
I. Basic Case Details
This case originated from a corporate debt restructuring dispute between the client, Mr. Li, and a competitor’s company. Due to conflicting commercial interests, the two parties engaged in civil litigation that lasted six years, all of which concluded with the competitor losing the cases. After failing to seize control of the company through civil means, the competitor turned to the judicial authorities to report clues suggesting that Mr. Li was suspected of crimes related to organized crime. Following prolonged reports, the judicial authorities initiated an investigation into Li’s case, designating a judicial authority in another jurisdiction to handle it; the municipal-level authority subsequently referred the case to the district-level public security bureau. During the investigation, the investigating authorities imposed the coercive measure of “residential surveillance at a designated location” on all eight suspects in the case, compiled all relevant evidence, and ultimately transferred the case to the prosecution for review, charging Li and others with crimes including organizing and leading a triad-like organization.
II. Points of Controversy
The points of controversy in this case center on both procedural and substantive aspects. On the one hand, significant issues exist regarding jurisdiction and the collection of evidence. First, the secondary designation of jurisdiction in this case lacked a legal basis. In organized crime cases, it is common for higher-level authorities, after obtaining jurisdiction, to subsequently designate lower-level authorities to handle the case; however, such actions generally lack a legal basis. Currently, Shandong Province is the only region nationwide to have enacted the *Implementation Measures for Designating Jurisdiction in Cases Involving Crimes of Organized Crime of a Triad Nature*, which imposes restrictions on the procedure by which municipal-level investigative authorities may re-designate jurisdiction to grassroots-level investigative authorities; other regions have no explicit regulations on this matter. In judicial practice, investigative authorities often routinely engage in such practices, and following the re-designation of jurisdiction, higher-level authorities continue to participate in the investigation and case handling process, thereby circumventing the rules of the jurisdiction system. This practice effectively artificially lowers the level of judicial review, preventing major and complex criminal cases—such as those involving organized crime—from being heard by higher-level judicial authorities, thereby constituting a deprivation of the parties’ legitimate rights to litigation. Second, the investigating authorities in this case imposed the coercive measure of “residential surveillance at a designated location” on all suspects involved in the case and even applied it to some key witnesses. There are significant doubts regarding the legality and authenticity of the relevant evidence.
On the other hand, from a substantive perspective, this case does not constitute organized crime. The entire case stemmed from a conflict of economic interests during the debt restructuring process between the two parties; there is no foundation for organized crime. The investigating authorities have elevated an economic organization that was involved in an isolated incident of violence to the status of an organized crime group. Upon review by the defense counsel, the so-called violent crimes were merely isolated acts committed incidentally by employees during the course of the company’s operations, rather than illegal or criminal activities instigated or organized by the company. These primarily included sporadic conflicts between the company’s security personnel and street vendors occupying public spaces, as well as actions by marine protection team members to disperse fishermen engaged in illegal fishing. Even if these actions were somewhat excessive, they do not constitute organized, premeditated, or sustained violent activities. The investigating authorities equated the company’s organizational structure with the hierarchical structure of a triad organization; characterized lawful and compliant market-oriented operations as illegal business activities; elevated employees’ occasional minor acts of violence to the level of organized criminal conduct; and treated the company’s legitimately accumulated industry advantages as evidence of social harm. These actions deviated from the established criteria for determining triad-related cases and constituted a misapplication of the four key characteristics of triad-like organizations.
III. Legal Representation
After the case was transferred for review and prosecution, the defense attorney immediately became involved and undertook defense work in the following four areas.
First, the attorney conducted multiple meetings to verify the facts of the case. Through long-term, continuous on-site meetings, the attorney reviewed the evidence in the case file item by item with Mr. Li, mapped out the complete sequence of events surrounding the economic dispute, visited the crime scenes in person, understood the causes and consequences of each violent crime, and clarified Mr. Li’s specific actions in each instance.
Second, the defense team verified and organized new evidence. Mr. Li’s company provided over a hundred pieces of evidence; the defense attorneys categorized this vast amount of evidence to form a comprehensive evidentiary framework and submitted over a thousand pages of new evidence to the procuratorate.
Third, we conducted a comprehensive review of the synchronized audio-visual recordings. Given that the investigating authorities had imposed the coercive measure of “residential surveillance at a designated location” on several individuals involved in the case, the legal team reviewed nearly 120 CDs containing the entire case to verify the authenticity and legality of the relevant confessions. We compiled and documented relevant issues and reported them to the procuratorate.
Fourth, drafting defense briefs and maintaining ongoing communication. Focusing on two key issues—procedural violations and erroneous substantive characterization—the lawyers drafted defense briefs that thoroughly argued the procedural defects in jurisdiction, problems in the evidence-gathering process, and the reasons why the case did not constitute a crime involving an organized crime syndicate. They met face-to-face with the prosecuting attorney six times to exchange views.
The prosecuting attorney attached great importance to the lawyers’ opinions and strictly adhered to legal standards, ultimately removing the “organized crime” charge during the review and prosecution stage. This interim achievement demonstrates the value of effective legal defense and highlights the role of defense work in promoting judicial fairness.



